Hold On, Player: Was a 19-year-old Buffalo woman stepping out with Prime Time?

Why So Serious? Stevie Johnson drops latest mixtape

Arts + Entertainment

Idina Menzel FTW!

Idina Menzel was a big hit with the BPO.

blog by Ben Kirst  • 

Indulge me for a moment: I want to call attention to the fact that a visit to Kleinhans for a buzzworthy show is an awesome experience.  I’m not even referring to the actual performance by Idina Menzel on Saturday night with the Buffalo Philharmonic Orchestra (which was great—more on that in a second)—I mean the whole set-up. 

Getting dressed up for a night out.  The heavy traffic on Porter Street around Symphony Circle.  Walking through those West Side streets, women’s heels clicking on the sidewalk.  Joining the flow of people into the Saarinen-designed concert hall.  Feeling like you’re stepping back into the 1940s. 

A drink in the foyer, quick to finish when the seating bell rings.  Find your seat with directions from a dapper usher.  All so pleasantly retro.  Delightful.

Idina Menzel is a Broadway actress whose celebrity bona fides were established in such high-profile shows as Rent and Wicked.  She’s also a legitimate TV star based on her supporting role in Glee.  Her appearance as the opening act in the BPO’s 2011-2012 Blue Cross/Blue Shield of Western New York Pops Series drew a house that appeared to be within a few dozen seats of a sellout, and that crowd—bolstered by a heavy teenage and young adult presence—was loud, proud and without reservation in their appreciation.

Menzel burst onstage like a ray of sunshine in her flowing canary-yellow, shoulder-less frock.  She opened with “The Life of the Party” from The Wild Party, a production that earned her a Drama Desk nomination in 2000.  Following some banter with the audience (including a winning moment in which she hustled to stage left, announcing “I’m going to stand over here, where all these boys are,” drawing a raucous ovation from that group of admirers), she transitioned into “I’m Not That Girl” from Wicked

Menzel, the original Elphaba in the Broadway and West End productions of the show, was playfully modest.

“Oh, you saw it?” she asked.  “I was the green one.”

Menzel then offered a unique medley of Cole Porter’s “Love For Sale” and “Roxanne” by The Police, using the selections to frame her soulful vocal phrasing and range.  She took advantage of the next piece—“Don’t Rain On My Parade” a tune made famous by Barbara Streisand—to comically frame her native Long Island accent.  When she reached the lyric, “Hey Mr. Arnstein, here I am,” she instead sang, “Hey Buffalo, here I am,” and struck a comically triumphant pose.  The crowd roared.

Menzel then rolled into “No Day But Today” from Rent.  Menzel was part of the original cast of that legendary show and she shared anecdotes from those heady days—meeting her husband (actor Taye Diggs—who is from Rochester, by the way.  I did not know that) in the production, backstage shenanigans with Diggs and other cast mates and, on a more somber note, dealing with the death of Rent’s writer / composer Jonathan Larson just before the show was set to open.  Her performance of “No Day But Today” was real and raw. The audience exploded when she was through.

And then there was Glee.  The mood lightened considerably as Menzel, who plays vocal coach Shelley Corcoran on the hit show, discussed her first duet with co-star Lea Michele and then led the BPO through that particular song: Lady Gaga’s “Poker Face.”

“I’m so sorry,” she told the orchestra.  “You probably went to Julliard, and here you are, playing this.”

The crowd loved the restructured version of the song, of course, and was equally pleased when Menzel offered examples of lullabies she and Diggs had created for their infant son—a hip-hop number about poop and a swinging wake-up song were particularly well-received.  Menzel burst into a Louis Prima number, “I Feel So Smootchie,” that ended with such a flourish that pockets of the audience gave Menzel a standing ovation. 

“Thank you so much,” she said.  “I’m not even from Buffalo, and you all came here to see me.”

Menzel then closed her performance a powerful a capella version of “For Good” from Wicked—you could have heard a pin drop in the hall—and when she finished, Kleinhans went bananas.  The young men next to me kept gasping “Oh my God.  Oh my God.” 

“I was going to ask them if they were OK,” my wife told me after the show.

Menzel left stage to a roaring standing ovation, then popped back out for a quick version of “Tomorrow” that she dedicated to her mother.  She disappeared, finally,  to another round of wild applause.  Menzel had won the evening.

UPDATE: Thanks to commenters Cheryl and Lindsey for refreshing my somewhat shoddy memory.


TAGGED: buffalo philharmonic orchestra, glee, idina menzel, kleinhans music hall, rent, wicked

Related Entries

Arts + Entertainment
	Photo of Idina Menzel at Kleinhans

Idina Menzel and the BPO dazzle the crowd at Kleinhans

Arts + Entertainment
Idina Menzel has the resume of a theatrical champion.

Broadway + Hollywood + Glee: Idina Menzel performs in Buffalo on Saturday

Arts + Entertainment
Buffalo.com / Robin David Brown

Ben Folds Five dazzles fans at Kleinhans - VIDEOS

Arts + Entertainment
Photo courtesy of Flickr / michaelhyman300

Remembering MLK

Leave a Comment

Please enter the word you see in the image below:


  1. Lindsey Mack-Bett September 18, 2011 @ 10:56am

    Idina’s last song was not “Somewhere Over the Rainbow,” it was “The Sun Will Come Out Tomorrow.”

    Lindsey Mack-Bett's avatar
  2. Cheryl Herrmann September 18, 2011 @ 2:10pm

    I enjoyed reading your review & agree that Kleinhans is an amazing venue. We are very fortunate to have it in the area. That being said, I feel the need to correct some errors in your review. Although, Ms. Menzel did sing “Defying Gravity” (and sang it beautifully), it was with full accompaniment. I believe the a cappella version you were referring to was “For Good” (also from Wicked). Also, as someone else pointed out, her final song was “Tomorrow” from Annie.

    Cheryl Herrmann's avatar
  3. Ben Kirst September 18, 2011 @ 3:23pm

    As for the Annie song: you’re right, I don’t know where that came from.  Got my standards crossed.  As for the other error…my mistake.  My only excuse is that it was dark when I took notes and early when I wrote the article.  Thanks for the help!  Edits forthcoming.

    Ben Kirst's avatar
  4. Samantha Jo September 18, 2011 @ 5:00pm

    Idina Menzel was breathtakingly beautiful during last night’s performance in Buffalo. I had been waiting all my life to see Idina perform and to actually see her in real life. My dream came true the moment she walked out on stage in her beautiful yellow flowing dress. She is my Barbara Streisand, my idol. Her voice and humor was a lifetime worth of happiness for me. What developed my love for her talent was her life changing role in Wicked. She tole my heart during the all time favorite song “Defying Gravity.” Tears rolled down my face the moment the orchestra began playing that song. My next dream will be to actually tell Idina how much I respect her talent and how inspiring she is to so many people. I was extremely disappointed she couldn’t stay to meet her Buffalo fans, so next time Idina; Please stay and chat!

    Samantha Jo's avatar