Five reasons why the NCAA Tournament is batty

Jason Pominville says ‘You Can Play’ - VIDEO


On the Tebow-to-Buffalo debate

blog by Ben Tsujimoto  • 

Would it make sense for the Bills to pursue Denver’s Tim Tebow, the gregarious, young quarterback suddenly expendable because of the Broncos’ addition of Peyton Manning? Denver announced yesterday that Tebow, who led the Broncos past the Pittsburgh Steelers in the playoffs before bowing out to New England, was available for trade. He’d be affordable, too, as the Broncos would only demand a mid-round pick in return. 

The initial arguments are quite vehemently against the Bills taking action; Jacksonville appears to be the early favorite, although CBS Sports lists Buffalo as a possible suitor.

1) Set at quarterback Buffalo already has an established franchise quarterback in Ryan Fitzpatrick, who signed a seven year, $62 million deal in late October last season.

2) Don’t rattle Fitz, Smith still there Even though “gadget players,” as Tebow would be if he didn’t come in as a full-time quarterback, are part of Chan Gailey’s philosophy, the Bills already have one in Brad Smith, who doesn’t serve as quite the threat to Fitzpatrick’s job as Tebow would.

3) Not the greatest fit Buffalo runs a very spread-heavy offense, and Tebow’s skill-set isn’t conducive to running such a timing-based system predicated on accurate, short passes. In order for Denver to have success last year, head coach John Fox had to revamp his entire game-plan, and with the Bills finally embracing Gailey’s philosophy, a change to accommodate Tebow makes little sense.

While these arguments sound logical enough, there’s merit to the reasons why pursuing Tebow wouldn’t be a bad idea:

1) He’s a PR machine: Think ticket sales exploded from the signing of Mario Williams? The gate would literally explode with the signing of Tim Tebow, a player beloved in every situation he’s been in. For a team that could use a healthy dose of positivity and hope, Tebow’s personality invigorates a locker room and creates a winning atmosphere, regardless of his role within the team.

2) He’s the consummate teammate: If Jacksonville sours on bringing in Tebow as its possible starting quarterback, every indication points to Tebow accepting a temporary smaller role as (if) he develops into an NFL passer. As a short yardage specialist, Tebow would allow the Bills to cut ties with Brad Smith and immediately improve Buffalo’s ability to move the chains in third-and-short situations, a problem area in the past.

3) The Bills’ reason for avoiding Tebow before is no longer relevant: Even though the Kelly family hosted Tebow for dinner before the 2010 draft, general manager Buddy Nix opted against taking the Florida Gator because the Bills couldn’t afford to be patient in his development. Now, with Fitzpatrick entrenched as the starter, Tebow could be groomed as his eventual successor in 2-3 years and would serve as a serious upgrade over Tyler Thigpen as the Bills’ backup.

4) Price: He’d only cost the Bills a fifth or sixth round pick, a modest salary and one roster spot. Does this sound like a small risk to anyone else?

Header photo courtesy of the Denver Broncos Facebook page.

TAGGED: buddy nix, buffalo bills, denver broncos, jim kelly, john elway, nfl trades, peyton manning, tebow trade, tim tebow

Related Entries


What the Sabres and Bills can learn from Tim Tebow


Jim Kelly roots for rocky times in Jets camp

Photo of the turf that Tim Tebow will have in his mouth.

Tim Tebow should dread December 24


Bills legend Jim Kelly diagnosed with cancer in his jaw

Leave a Comment

Please enter the word you see in the image below:


  1. Bobby Corp March 20, 2012 @ 10:24am

    i dont think im with you on this one, and this is coming from a tebow “fan.” i strongly disagree with the notion that tebow as a short yardage specialist would make ticket sales explode - his impact, as spelled out by you, would be only a fraction of mario’s on the field.

    i can’t find the numbers right now, but i think i remember brad smith actually being super effective in short yardage utilziation, and that the team just had to go away from it in the second half of the year due to lack of depth at wr. i think that brad gives more versatility than tebow at this point in their careers, and i don’t really know what giving up one for the other really proves (not to mention the sunk costs it would bring from brad’s guaranteed money).

    tebow’s presence would certainly increase the pressure on fitz, and i don’t think we need blowhards on wgr clamoring for tim after fitz’s first tough outing. i just dont see it being worth the drama.

    Bobby Corp's avatar
  2. bkirst09 March 20, 2012 @ 10:30am

    I love it! Make it happen. Chan Gailey likes working with these multi-tool athletes. Tebow’s a winner, a great teammate, a marketing wonder and he’ll have two years to figure out how to throw the ball. Move him into Jim Kelly’s basement, hang a tire from the tree in the backyard and get this guy in a Bills jersey.

    bkirst09's avatar